Friday, 31 October 2008

Halloween and the spirit of the brewery


I've always liked Wychwoods advertising because of the way it takes the micky out of lager drinkers. It's nice to see that at this time of year the beer is to be found all over the place, it's fitting that this type of marketing can work to produce a grand success.

Stonch has got some for Halloween and when I went to my friends pub last night I found he also had the same, tacky LED pumpclip on display.

The problem I have is that the marketing gives me the impression that the beer is made in a small microbrewery, all hand crafted and the like. I very much doubt that with the sudden increase of sales this Halloween, that all the Hobgoblin being sold tonight will have been brewed in the same brewery. If anybody can confirm, for sure, that every drop is still brewed in the Wychwood brewery then fine, but I'd be surprised if this market penetration is supported by production at the original site.

I am sure that Marstons have capitalised on this seasonal event and brewed as much of the stuff in as many of their breweries as they could manage. They have sold it all over the country in their various pub estates and free trade outlets. Good for them.

It's all fine, so long as we realise that the beer and the brewery are now a very separate thing. Hobgoblin is a product. It's marketed under the name of Wychwood and a very good job is made of that. Marstons, who have a reasonable track record of keeping breweries going, are not really interested in the brewing capacity of the Wychwood brewery. Make no doubt about it they are interested in the ability to use the established trading name. They can combine a good product and it's marketing with the companies ability to distribute. The beer can be brewed anywhere and still be called Wychwood Hobgobblin because the names are now owned by Marstons.

My point is that during a time of shrinking beer market overall, there is no requirement to increase brewing capacity. Additionally to this we have an increase in success of the smaller breweries. Small breweries start up, some become successful and get bigger, really successful ones get bought up by even more successful ones until eventually they get bought by regional and nationals. Along the way some brewery sites will close, it's inevitable.

If we, the beer enthusiasts, want to see new beers then we also have to accept that this progress will also result in some failures. Beers will eventually move to new sites and despite concerns over the water being different I believe reasonable facsimiles can be made. The problem with the real ale market is that the typical real ale fan enjoys the variety. They like new ales to try: market penetration can only go so far. Once we started brewing our own and putting it on the bar, the likes of Jennings beers started to fall out of favour with our customers. Maybe this was partly due to the increased saturation of the market that the take over by Marstons caused or maybe by the fact that my beers, brewed on the premises were more attractive being rarer, but the effect was definitely there.

When I started out my drinking career in the early 80's the one brewery's beer that seemed to be sought after was Theakstons, probably rightly so. Today it is very much seen by many as old hat and boring. This is, I believe, the effect of the massive market saturation achieved by S&N when it took over. Having said all that, I still like Old Peculiar as my all time favorite beer.

As Ron says the location of the brewery might have some relevance to the beer being produced, but I believe not as much as many beer drinkers would like to believe. What the discerning ale drinker still wants is some feeling that the beer is special, this is something that the national brewers understand, they understand that a beer that is revered, like Hobgoblin, has some merit. The charm is lost when the product is pushed too far.

I do worry that as happened with Theakstons in the hands of S&N, many very revered names, like Hobgoblin, Jennings and maybe even Pedigree will eventually loose their charm as the big breweries use and abuse the good name, suck out the juice and throw away what's left. It seems to have happened with Theakstons, thankfully that name has withdrawn back into the family with good success.

The good news is that the diverse beer market is strong and forever changing. Rather than bemoaning the closure of breweries we should celebrate that big breweries need to keep their offering exciting. We should also be really happy that there are so many new microbreweries and brew pubs springing up. This cannot happen without some changes, and failures, at the other end of the scale.

Energy for beer cooling.

I thought that the general pub goer might be interested in knowing how much it costs to keep the beer at the correct temperature.


These figures represent the profit from the first 10 pints of beer sold per day.

The bar staff represent 60 pints per day minimum on a 12 hour opening schedule. General heating and lighting at least another 20 pints per day, insurance at least 10 pints per day. It is estimated that legislation could now be costing the typical pub outlet £30,000 per year. That's 80 pints per day.

Many small community pubs just can't get to these volumes, no where near in fact.

These figures are not all based on precise scientific methods, but the ball park is not far away - the point is many customers just don't think about the costs that the pub has to cover for the environment that is provided.

Thursday, 30 October 2008

Original Mountian Marathon

I'm going to stray a little from the subject of beer for this post, but it is related to the subject in a diverse way. It is an example, in this case extreme, of how a business that is providing a public service can have costs lumbered onto it by people who are not significant customers. A problem that is significant in The Lake District.

I have been following the difficulties of the Original Mountain Marathon that was held last weekend. There has been significant criticism of the event on the grounds of the safety of the competitors and the costs to the emergency services. The manager of the Honister Slate mines, who was inconvenienced by the shear number of casualties who sheltered at his mine, has spoken out about the event.

I have been a keen outdoor enthusiast in the past. I've been a rock climber and hill walker, been to the Alps and got stuck in a crevasse in a glacier and done all manner of activities where I put my life at risk. I like our mountain rescue system the way it is and the fact that generally individuals are not held too much in account for their actions. If we changed the system we would have a terrible litigation problem where blame was placed, inappropriately, on people for organising dangerous activities.

The organisers of the OMM must take stock of the event and decide for themselves if their actions were appropriate. I do believe though, that the competitors were taking part with eyes wide open. They knew the dangers of the mountains, it is an event for hardened athletes. How the costs of the public services are met might be an issue to be discussed between organisers and the emergency services, but as the organisers are, I believe, volunteers, their should be a "there for the grace of god go I" attitude.

The impact of these events on the businesses that do not benefit from such events can be great. There is hardly a day goes by at my location without some poor fell walker who has come off the mountain the wrong side, car driver who has had a double blowout on the pass or lost tourist asking for help and using staff time without spending money - or the traveler who just wishes to use the toilet without buying a drink.

I am not surprised that Mike Weir, who is the manager of The Honister Slate Mines, is a little upset about the event.

In David Pickthalls report in a local paper, there is comment by the organisers of the event saying that it brings in revenue to the lake district. That, I'm afraid, is not significant. The Three Peaks challenge, the OMM and orienteering events such as these put pressure on the infrastructure and businesses of the Lake District that far outweigh any revenue.

The main point is that it puts costs on the Lake District businesses without due return in revenue. A pub is one such type of Lake District business. This in turn puts up the price of the Lake District pint.

Monday, 27 October 2008

A pint- the only thing

Well after such interesting thoughts on 2/3 of a pint on Tandlemans blog, I thought I might share my thoughts on The Pint.

I am a chef, as well as a brewer and publican. As a chef I understand the importance of sampling a whole dish as it will be delivered to the customer. You can taste the sauce and a bit of the meat, check the vegetables are correctly salted and cooked just right, but the whole effect is just not apparent until you've tried the whole dish - is it balanced?

A beer is the same. You can have a taster. Maybe even 1/3 pint. But until you have had a full, imperial pint measure, the whole volume as consumed by most beer drinkers, you have not appreciated the full effect of the beer.

Now as a brewer and publican, I have the rather arduous job of performing this task - testing the beers. Every beer I have on my bar is sampled, in the full pint, to the line you understand, head extra. Because real ale can go "off" so quickly, it is important to do this every day. When you have 6 hand pulls running then every one has to be sampled every day in full pint samples.

Boy, its a tough job - but I do it for you, the discerning beer drinker - the problem is, some beers are just tooo good to stop at one pint........

Tonight just 4:

Stout Tenacity - Hardknott
Saazy Lamm - Hardknott
Wicked Jimmey - Cumbrian Legendary Ales
Old Faithful - Tirrel

Wicked Jimmey is my favourite out of these.

Price of ale

I keep thinking about putting a post on here about the price of beer. There is already one that is close to what I would like to say on The Woolpack Blog.

The only real addition to this is that most licensees do not make a large amount of money - many struggle to make a profit at all and too many make a loss.

Remember that 5p less on a pint of beer might be ALL the licensees profit GONE.

There are many examples all over the place about the price of beer being too high. For example, the very important discussion about measures on Tandlemans blog is distracted by this very issue.

If beer was too expensive pubs would not be shutting down at the rate of 36 per week. We licensees would be gleefully raking in the profits and fighting to keep open our goldmines!!

Saturday, 25 October 2008

Held to ransom

Customer care is crucial to the success of every hospitality business. It can be so difficult to get it right, but it is important to make customers feel welcome and try and be sympathetic when the service they receive doesn't match their expectations. An establishment needs to set out it's stall and define the product that is being delivered. That can be difficult to do when so many people have so many different ideas about what a pub should deliver. When the product that is being tendered is not delivered satisfactorily then dealing with customer grievances is important. Ensuring the customer understands the product can be key to that and in a pub situation can be very difficult to get across what products and service are delivered and what is not.

It seems to me that there is an increase of demands from customers for you to deliver exactly what the customer wants, another pint after your official licensing time or serving of food after the kitchen staff have cleaned up the kitchen. There seems to be an increasing attitude from customers that states, subliminally "you NEED my custom, I don't care if my demands are unreasonable, you can just do it because otherwise I'll not come here again and I'll tell all my mates not to"

Last night, after we had served some nice customers with food, we were all sat in the bar chatting and having a nice pint. (I was drinking Keswick's Thirst Chestnut). The kitchen was clean and the kitchen staff had clocked off. Due to our location we expected we might not get any more customers so we settled in to make the few we had nice and comfortable. It's one of the nice things about our job, talking with nice people about so many different things.

A car turned into the Car park, it seemed to be a very new, nice black shiny Discovery. Ann went behind the bar to be ready for the new addition to our friendly little group. These people turned out to be rather unsavoury kind of folk. I can be a little snobby sometimes, normally with lager drinkers, or people who can't understand why we don't do scampi. On this occasion I think these customers beat me hands down.

Marching to the bar they told us they wanted a bottle of wine and some cheese, in quite a demanding fashion. We told them that the kitchen was closed, but they could have a bottle of wine if they liked. They told us they had been to us before and not found it good but had heard that we had improved. We certainly do believe we have improved, but it seemed to be that if we did not provide the cheese they would not stay to find out.

Now we do a rather nice cheese board, all local Cumbrian cheeses. We might even have been tempted to serve them if they had approached the subject correctly. However, I'm quite convinced that their attitude may just have spoiled the evening and I'm sure we were right to restate that we had stopped serving food and that we would be happy to sell them a bottle of wine.

But all present had a good laugh at their snobby, demanding rudeness. We continued to drink beer. Ann though did insist on drinking Kreik - beer oughtn't to taste of cherries!!

Thursday, 23 October 2008

The Tied Pub - for and against

The beer tie and pub companies (pubco's) are being blamed for much of the trouble that pubs are suffering. I'm not altogether convinced that this is true. I am however against the beer tie as I believe it restricts the potential of the craft brewed market, limits customer choice and is a monopoly which exploits the aspirations of up and coming licensees often dashing all their dreams of running a good pub. Conversely it has also provided many people with the ability to gain a foothold on the ladder of pub management, one that they might otherwise have been unable to attain.

In this piece, I intend to explore some of the advantages and disadvantages in a constructive way. I hope, that if nothing else, it might provide an insight for the prospective pub entrepreneur into the various methods of starting out with your own pub business. Careful shopping around at this time, if you can finance the right project, could be very lucrative. Although the pub market is in a bad way, there is the possibility that it will turn around some time soon. As they say, invest when the market is at the bottom, it's judging when the bottom is. It could be a very exciting market to be getting into for those who are brave enough.

The models of ownership

There are 4 basic models of ownership: managed, tenanted, leased and freehold. All these can have a tie associated with them. Freehold is much less likely to have a tie and is only very subtle in the form of a loan with strings, it only requires alternative financing to enable the removal of tie. All other forms normally, although not always, have a tie of some form or another. There is however normally only a tie on the wet trade so the pub that does food or even better has rooms will have various areas of the business with better freedom.

Before I proceed though, I have to point out that whatever model of ownership is in force the thing that will effect success more than anything else is location of the property. I will look at this in more detail later but a pub that is located near centers of permanent population will always do better. Where there is the ability for several pubs to survive in a close proximity, they can often feed off each other, provide a pub "circuit" or an area known for diversity. For location, I would argue that where one pub has a population of less than 500 within a 1 mile radius there is doubt about it's viability. There are special cases in tourist locations, but weather and seasonal effects can make it difficult to make a pub viable where the vast majority of the trade is from visitor numbers.

I am not going to discuss in any details the managed or tenanted model more than to say these properties normally offer the licensee the ability to run a pub without any risk of his own capital. Handing back the keys and walking away is often an option without loosing out. The risk is low but the gains are also likely to be low.

The tied lease

The vast majority of tied pubs after this are leased. There are free of tie leases available but they are not as common. When you "buy" a lease, you are paying for the right to operate the business that runs the operation in the pub building. This lease has a value and the value of the lease is influenced by how well the business runs: a combination of turnover and profit. The building is owned by somebody else, often a pubco or brewery. The responsibility of the owner of the building and the owner of the lease will have been defined when the lease was drawn up by the property owner, although with a new lease there is sometimes a chance to negotiate the terms.

The terms of the lease will determine such things as who is responsible for maintenance of various aspects. Some leases will require the lessee to carry out all necessary work. Often though the property owners will ensure the fabric of the building is maintained and internal decor, fixtures and fittings becomes the responsibility of the lease.

Most importantly the lease will state where the lessee may purchase various product from. In a tied lease much of the "wet" product, i.e. beer, wine and spirits will need to be bought through the property owner, sometimes this can also extend to soft drinks and occasionally food. Sometimes though there is an agreement where flexibility of the tie is permitted.

The cost of buying a lease is a fraction of what it would cost to buy the freehold of the same property. Sometimes it can be a significant portion and sometimes less so. It is though, a significantly less expensive option than a freehold in most cases. There is a bias to this as leased properties tend to be better located for reasons I will come on to. Better location results in a better trade which results in the business being worth more.

Pros and cons of the tie

A significant advantage of the tied lease model is the great support that the pubco or brewery gives to the licensee. They will normally look after such things as the building infrastructure and significantly invest where this is required. If the pub needs a new roof, then it will get one. If the electrics are not to regulations then they will be upgraded. Wet rot, dry rot, rising damp and subsidence should never be a problem for long to the leased pub licensee.

A further advantage is that there is often significant support to deal with legislate issues such as employment law, health and safety and accessibility. Training is often provided and support for cellar management are all provided at either reduced prices or without cost. In short the leased model has inherent built in support. It was recently estimated that current legislative overheads now accounts for £30,000 on average per property.

The leased model has it's disadvantages. For a start the whole of the licensees investment is into the pub business. His only assets are often a few tables and chairs and maybe the kitchen equipment, most of which will have very little second hand value. The majority of the capital he puts into the project is to buy a viable business. If this business turns out to not be viable and folds, he looses everything he has put in.

Free of tie

The free house does have huge advantages. The initial investment costs are normally significantly more but the licensee will have full ownership of the property. A bank may have first call in the event of bankruptcy, but by and large this is a technicality. The property itself would normally have intrinsic value in the bricks and mortar. Even if the pub business were to fail then the owner may still sell the property, although it's value may be reduced due to there being no viable business at a commercial property and the problems associated with applying for a change of use.

It is then, somewhat easier to purchase the lease on a pub than the freehold. But I'd like to explore that a little. As the lease on the pub only has intrinsic value while the business is viable, it can be harder to get a loan. Any loan would have to be an unsecured loan with higher interest rates and the proportion put up by the prospective licensee would have to be greater. For this reason it is often the case that the new lessee will be putting all he has into the business. This can often be the equity in any property he might currently own. Conversely it is perfectly possible to put the equity of many houses owned by 40ish year olds into the deposit for a reasonable freehold property and get a mortgage for the rest. In my limited experience of looking at purchasing freehold against lessee hold the deposit is not that much different.

The current credit situation does make this rather more difficult just now, but then everything is a bit difficult right now. It is important to remember though, and I can't stress this enough, with the leased model, if the licensee fails he will loose everything, but the pubco or brewery will still have the freehold title to the property, the property owner, the pubco or brewery, is putting up very little risk. The leasehold model is there to pass the risk on to licensees and away from pub companies and breweries.

Forming a monopoly

It has become apparent to me that very successful free houses tend to be the properties that get bought up by the pubco's and breweries. They are prepared to pay just that little bit more for the ownership of a very successful pub as it is guaranteed to provide a significant outlet for their own product. This has resulted in a bias in the trade. As mentioned above the location of the pub is going to provide success over and above the type of beer sold, quality or style of food or the friendliness of the staff. Not that I'm diminishing the value of these pub features, but it still remains a fact that some pubs are much harder to run due to location and some will be much easier. The pubco's and breweries avoid like mad the more difficult to run establishments, the ones that rely on food and accommodation for the majority of the revenue, basically, the ones where the location results in low beer volume. The remainder that are in the free trade are more marginal, as a rule or are not true pubs but diverse pubs that might be simply a public bar in a hotel or similar.

Where the tied pub is really a problem is in the removal of customer choice. There will always be a restriction on what the landlord is permitted to sell. A tied pub will almost never sell micro brewed ale. The economics of it will not permit this to happen. Pubco's and breweries own pubs so that they can sell their beer into these tied estates and make money out of the pseudo monopoly it creates. Without this commercial advantage of owning tied pub estates they would not be investing in pubs. In short, it's a double edged sword that cuts at the pub industry.

It's down to choice

The reason that the tied houses work is because both licensees and customers alike choose to get involved. Without customers who patronise these establishments they would not work. People who are looking to run their own pub find the leased property as a perceived lower risk and lower cost option. I don't believe this is the case, but perceived like that it is.

If every person who was looking at investing into the pub trade thought very carefully about what they're taking on there would probably be less successful leases taken out. If every customer looked twice at the beer range and realised that they had chosen a tied house then the free house model would do better.

The most disgracefully action of pubco's is the act of putting a failed tied house on the free market with a covenant on it to prevent it ever being used again as a pub. I am all for free houses that have failed being allowed to be sold and converted to dwellings if the alternative is for a licensee, who has put his life's worth and more into a pub, to loose everything. But it must be tested on the free market first. There are examples of tied houses, where the pub company has competing property close by,  are being sold with a legal covenant that prevents it being opened as a pub.

We do have to remember that there are some good tied houses out there. Generally the vast majority of the general public like the product that is delivered by the tied houses as it represents a consistent and reliable product. This is the same reason of course that keg beers still take up the majority of the market. Bland and predictable is what the majority of consumers want.

Disclaimer - I am not an expert on the legal issues surrounding leasehold's and it is possible I have some details wrong. Please seek independent  expert advise if you are thinking of taking on a leasehold. This independent advise will not come from a brewery, pubco or estate agent. I would recommend the BII in the first instance.
As this is an important issue, please comment on any inaccuracies as I believe we need the issues into the open, as I've said, if for no other reason than to advise new licensees.